Government Not Needed

I was under the impression that after a natural disaster the only way the region can recover is by massive federal intervention. But then I read this about Hoover when he helped with the Mississippi flooding:

In early 1927, the Great Mississippi River flood broke the banks and levees of the Mississippi River. Although such a disaster did not fall under the duties of the Commerce Department, the governors of six states along the Mississippi specifically asked for Herbert Hoover in the emergency, so President Calvin Coolidge sent Hoover to mobilize state and local authorities, militia, army engineers, Coast Guard, and the American Red Cross. He set up health units, with a grant from the Rockefeller Foundation, to work in the flooded regions for a year. These workers stamped out malaria, pellagra, and typhoid fever from many areas. His work during the flood brought Herbert Hoover to the front page of newspapers almost everywhere, and he gained new accolades as a humanitarian. The great victory of his relief work, he stressed, was not that the government rushed in and provided all assistance. Rather, it was that much of the assistance available was provided instead by private citizens and organizations in response to Hoover’s appeals. “I suppose I could have called in the Army to help,” he said, “but why should I, when I only had to call upon Main Street.”

Wait so people are capable of repairing their homes and towns without the federal government providing massive funding. Surely you jest.

7 Responses to “Government Not Needed”

  1. darwin Says:

    Don’t you think it’s pretty disengenuous to tilte a post ‘Government Not Needed’ and then post a text excerpt about how someone mobilized many different parts of local governments in order to solve a problem without intervention from the federaql government?

  2. steve Says:

    From the passage I quoted in the post:

    The great victory of his relief work, he stressed, was not that the government rushed in and provided all assistance. Rather, it was that much of the assistance available was provided instead by private citizens and organizations in response to Hoover’s appeals.

  3. darwin Says:

    “so President Calvin Coolidge sent Hoover to mobilize state and local authorities, militia, army engineers, Coast Guard, and the American Red Cross.”

    Yes, private citizens can help a lot. But from this description it hardly seems like no government was needed.

  4. steve Says:

    Lame. Is your contention that private citizens require federal assistance in a catastrophe?

  5. darwin Says:

    It’s my contention that it helps alot, yeah.

  6. Jamie Says:

    Steve only favors our governments assistance in helping other countries. Not our own.

  7. Dan Says:

    It sounds like the government, even if not ‘needed’, was instrumental and effective in organizing and supporting the efforts of private citizens.

Leave a Reply